Medicare Open Enrollment Is Open Season for Scammers: How Florida Seniors Stay Covered, Not Scammed

It is open enrollment season for Medicare, and that means one thing to criminals up and down the Sunshine State: it is time to call Florida seniors with a story that sounds just real enough. The call I keep hearing about goes like this. A Florida senior’s phone rings during open enrollment, the caller ID looks official, and the voice on the line delivers the punch: Your Medicare coverage is being cancelled. Verify your number right now or lose your benefits in January.

Here is the part worth telling every senior you love: in the version of this story I know, the senior spotted the pressure, said thank you, hung up, and called Florida’s free SHINE counselors instead. Shine is the state’s free, unbiased Medicare counseling program, and it exists exactly for moments like this. The coverage was never cancelled. There was nothing to verify. The call was a script, and the script lost to a calm head.

Open enrollment is live from October 15 through December 7, and any plan changes take effect January 1. That window is scammers’ peak season: the FTC, AARP, and the Better Business Bureau all confirm that fraud surges while millions of seniors are choosing coverage. The good news is that you have the whole window to compare, to ask, and to verify, and the people who insist you decide this minute are the people to say goodbye to.

The six plays, in one glance

Six scripts cover almost everything Florida seniors will hear this window. None of them survives a hang-up and a callback to a number you already know:

Red flags at a glance

If you hear any of these, you already know the script:

• Red flag 01 Urgency and pressure: act right now or lose coverage

• Red flag 02 Caller ID spoofing, since any name or number can be faked

• Red flag 03 Demands for your Medicare, Social Security, or bank numbers

• Red flag 04 Payment by gift card, wire transfer, or cryptocurrency

• Red flag 05 A 'new card' fee, because Medicare never charges for your card

• Red flag 06 Free equipment or tests that only need your Medicare number

• Red flag 07 Web addresses that look almost like Medicare.gov but are not

• Red flag 08 Demands to decide immediately, with no time to check

If a scam call finds you, this is your plan

1. 1

   Hang up. You never owe a stranger a conversation.

2. 2

   Never share your Medicare number with a caller, ever.

3. 3

   Verify with Medicare at 1-800-MEDICARE on your own card.

4. 4

   Call Florida SHINE for free, unbiased answers at 1-800-963-5337.

5. 5

   Report it to the FTC at reportfraud.ftc.gov and call 1-866-9-NO-SCAM.

6. 6

   Tell a trusted person. Secrecy is the scammer's best friend.

Stay covered, not scammed

The senior who catches the scam wins. That sentence is the whole point of this season, and of my Senior Scams series. Make your own calls, hang up on pressure, never share your Medicare number with a caller, and run any plan past a free SHINE counselor before you switch. That is how Florida seniors stay covered, and it is how families turn open enrollment into the safest season of the year.

Talk Soon